Society · Research · Education
Critical thinking weakens when AI substitutes for thinking
A study in Nature’s Humanities and Social Sciences Communications examined the relationship between perceived AI intelligence and critical thinking among university students. The finding is not one-directional: students who see the tools as more intelligent engage with them in ways associated with stronger critical thinking. Where the wider literature converges is this: critical thinking erodes when AI substitutes for human reasoning and use is unguided. What matters is not the tool but how it is used.
Sources
- Humanities and Social Sciences Communications (Nature Portfolio), “Outsourcing thinking to AI? Focused immersion, AI dependency, and the double-edged impact on critical thinking”, (nature.com)
- Microsoft Research / Carnegie Mellon University, “The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking: Self-Reported Reductions in Cognitive Effort and Confidence Effects From a Survey of Knowledge Workers” (microsoft.com)
- Societies (MDPI), “AI Tools in Society: Impacts on Cognitive Offloading and the Future of Critical Thinking”, (mdpi.com)
- MIT Media Lab, “Your Brain on ChatGPT: Accumulation of Cognitive Debt when Using an AI Assistant for Essay Writing Task”, (media.mit.edu)
About this story
This story was posted on Instagram by @jarrus.tech on Sept. 28, 2026.
Spotted an error in this story? [email protected] · Instagram
Short link: thejarrus.com/en/critical-thinking
This story in Turkish: Yapay zeka düşünmenin yerine geçtiğinde eleştirel düşünme zayıflıyor
On the same topic
Robot tests: even the best model completed only 19% of 84 robot tasks, and 63 tasks were solved by no model
In RobotWorld, a benchmark released October 7, the top model, GPT-6 Astra, completed only 16 of 84 simulated robot tasks; no model solved 63 of the tasks.
OpenAI’s image model posts a near-perfect score on text-dense images
On UltraText Bench, a dense-text test led by Westlake University, OpenAI’s GPT Image 2 ranked first of 24 configurations with 99.35 out of 100.
Anthropic is running a lab that does biology experiments in the Bay Area
Anthropic runs a Bay Area biology lab where it aims to have Claude direct automated lab equipment under human supervision, with a focus on fundamental biology.